Band saw vs. table saw, a very common fight in the world of woodworking. This is more of confusion than a fight. Both of them are very common woodworking power tools and also most effective for getting accurate results. You will find them in almost all the workshops and garages all over the world.
Most of the amateurs are confused because they don’t understand whether they will buy table saw or band saw as both does relatively same type of cutting. Are you confused about band saw vs. table saw as well? Chill, we’ll let you know some tidbits which you should know to decide coming across the ‘popular’ confusion of band saw vs. table saw.
About Table Saw
In general, a table saw is better-rounded tool and has a greater range of use than the band saw. This is probably the first tool you should purchase while planning for a woodworking workshop or a home garage. This is really a standard woodworking power tool. You can say a table saw is an almighty saw, yes it is. A circular saw, a miter saw can do what a table saw can do, but none of them can do with such perfection, ease and efficiency that you get from a table saw.
There is no other option but purchasing a quality table saw and spend some time with the table saw and its user manual to understand the tool, if you want to be a woodworking expert. With all its features, it can really do anything and everything that you need to do as a woodworking craftsman.
About Band Saw
The band saw has its specific functions and uses. They can perform some cutting that is virtually impossible for a table saw. Okay, but it is never recommended that you purchase a band saw before a table saw. The band saw can cut curves and cut thick pieces of woods that a table saw cannot cut. Band saw can perform the cuts that a table saw does, but fir the type of blade, a table saw is much more effective for those general cuts.
Band Saw vs. Table Saw
Now we will be talking about the differences between a band saw and a table saw in some specific operations.
Types of cutting
Table saw and band saw do same type of cutting, but only band saw or only table saw can’t perform every type of cut perfectly. They are master in different type of cut.
If you need a long straight cut, no other saw will help you like a table saw. The thing you have to do is to set the fence and turn it on. You can cut pieces in exactly repeatable size in a table saw. Table saw is mostly used for two purposes. One is to make wide boards narrower and another is to cut long boards shorter. Also table saws will help you most to cut wide pieces, tanons and dados accurately. Some table saws will help you to cut bevel by tilting the blade. Again table saw is more powerful than band saw.
But if you want to cut a curve or cut woods thicker than 3.5”, band saw will beat table saw definitely. If you want a bevel cut by band saw, you have to adjust the material itself. In the war of band saw vs. table saw, band saw also wins when you need to cut curves or other irregular shapes. That’s why you can make tighter radius curves and perfect scrolling work by a band saw. Again band saw is perfect for working on smaller details where table saw fails most of the time. Band saw blades leave a rough edge in the material. But table saw blades cut it smoothly. So people generally use table saws if smooth edge is a must.
Both band saw and table saw are versatile but their versatility is on different field. While band saw is versatile in case of material, table saw is versatile in case of cutting capabilities. You can cut not only wood but also metal, plastic or meat without damaging the blade. But table saw won’t give you this advantage. Table saw is perfect for wood, but not perfect for plastic or metal. If you use for cutting plastic or metal, the blade will be damaged. Table saw will enable you to cut in more different ways than a band saw.
Kerfs and Noise
Kerfs are the slits, made by cutting materials with saw. Definitely kerfs are annoying and it is a type of dust. So you will prefer kerfs as less as possible. Table saw produce much more kerfs than the band saw. The reason is the blade of band saw is thinner than the blade of a table saw. Kerfs can be reason for some health problems. So for you it might be a point to think of.
In case of noise, band saw is better than table saw. Yes, here too. When table saw produces too much noise, noise produce from band saw is comparatively much lower. But you can use blade stabilizer or open cell foam as possible solution for controlling noise emitted from table saw.
You will need more space to place a table saw than a band saw in your shop. For better performance you have to place it in the middle of your workshop. But you can place band saw at any corner of your shop.
If your workplace is really big, you don’t need to be much concerned about the space needed for the saw, but still design of the workplace matters. If you have less space, band saw will be better for that.
Again table saw is difficult to move from here to there without any assistance. But if you think of band saw, that is easier to move than table saw. You will be able to move a band saw without the help of others.
In the war of band saw vs. table saw, safety is a point for most of the people. Some prefer band saw because table saw is considered as most dangerous among all the power saws. Band saw is much safer than table saw. Table saw cuts towards you, so you might get hurt by anything stuck in the saw, though it is a very rare problem. On the other hand band saw cuts to down, so this problem doesn’t happen in band saw.
But in the case of saw, every saw is dangerous when you start it. They are safe only when they are stopped. So if you use safety gears and work carefully, it won’t be a matter whether you are using table saw or band saw or other saws.
Band saw is cheaper than table saw. You can continue your work safely and accurately with a cheap band saw. But if you buy a cheap table saw, you will face a lot of problems to operate it. You have to be more careful when you are using a cheap table saw. So if price is a major criterion, it’ll be better to choose band saw.
If you are really looking for a decision on band saw vs. table saw, there is no exact winner. Each is master in different task. So you have to choose one which goes perfect with your task. Most of the beginner starts with table saw, being sure about safety tidbits. But if you want to work with creativity, band saw will be better for you. But it’s better to have both of the tools if you have enough space and purchasing power.